she should consider marriage. But not now, and not to that gardener.
âI understand why you find him attractive,â her mother had written. âBut young people today donât have to be married to have sex. You can do that, if you must, and get it out of your system without ruining your chances with someone better. Besides, if you marry him, the sexual attraction will fade once the novelty wears off, and then where will you be?â
Carolâs signature followed, as if anyone else could have written such a hateful letter. There was a postscript, but Sarahâs hands trembled, rattlingthe paper so that the words blurred and she could barely make them out: âPlease know that my feelings are specifically about you and your friend. They are not a reflection of my relationship with your father. We had a happy, loving marriage that ended too soon.â
At once, Sarah snatched up the phone and dialed her motherâs number. When she answered, Sarah didnât return her greeting. âDonât you ever, ever spew such filth about Matt again,â she snapped. âDo you hear me? Do you understand?â
She slammed down the phone without waiting for a reply.
The letters halted, and despite her earlier threats, a few months later Carol came to the small wedding in Eisenhower Chapel on the Penn State campus. She spoke politely with Mattâs father, posed for pictures as the photographer instructed, and wept no more than was appropriate. Sarah could hardly look at her, could hardly bear to be in the presence of someone so spiteful to the man she loved. She knew Matt sensed the tension that sparkled and crackled between them, and hoped he attributed it to the inherent stress of the occasion.
The memory of those letters stung as sharply as if she had received them only yesterday.
âWhat do you think, Sarah?â Sylvia asked, startling her out of her reverie.
âOh.â Sarah carried a bunch of carrots to the sink to wash them. âWhatever you want to do is fine with me.â
âYou havenât heard a word Iâve said, have you?â
Sarah shook the water from the carrots. âNo. Iâm sorry.â She avoided meeting Sylviaâs eyes as she returned to the counter. âIâve been thinking about our newest camper.â She picked up a knife, lined up a carrot on the cutting board, and chopped off its top with a sharp whack.
Sylviaâs eyebrows rose as she watched the cutting board. âI see.â She wiped her hands on her apron. âTell me. What brought about this estrangement? Did your mother abuse you? Neglect you?â
Sarah dispatched another carrot with a few strong chops of the knife. âNo.â As angry as she was at her mother, it wouldnât be fair to accuse her of that.
âWhat was it, then? It must have been something truly horrible, the way you two act around each other.â
âItâs hard to explain.â Sarah divided the carrot slices among four large salad bowls and began cutting up the rest of the bunch. âSometimes I wish she had done something bad enough to justify cutting her out of my life altogether. As a mother, Iâm afraid she was all too typical. Lots of mothers constantly criticize their daughters, right?â
Sylvia shrugged.
âThatâs what my mother did. Does. Nothing I do is ever good enough for her. For most of my life Iâve been knocking myself out trying to please her, but itâs useless. Itâs like she thinks Iâm not living up to my potential just to spite her.â
âIâm sure your mother is proud of you, even if she doesnât always show it.â
âI wish I could be so sure.â
Sylvia opened the oven door to check on the chickens. âYou do love her, though, donât you?â
âOf course I love her.â Sarah hesitated, then forced herself to say the rest. âI just donât like her very much. Believe me, the