and chance. She was not very tall; her hair was blackâthick, heavy hair which she wore in elaborate curls.
She said, lifting a cigarette she held in her hand with a gesture demanding a light from someone: âWell, why, please?â
Toby took out a matchbox. âI donât know,â he said.
âOh, please. You were just going to tell the inspector.â
âNo,â said Toby. âI was just telling the inspector that for some reason Lou didnât want to meet you. For some reason. She wouldnât tell me what the reason was.â
She smiled at him. If there was a fault in her appearance it was that when she smiled it made little difference to her face.
âYou tried to make her tell you the reason, of course?â
âYes, I tried to make her tell me.â
âAnd she was just hysterical, evasive and muddled up?â
Vanner broke in: âThen you know yourself, Miss Merton, why she didnât want to go back to your flat?â
âNo,â she answered composedly, âLou was always getting into states of mind I didnât understand at all.â
âWell,â said Toby to Vanner, âshall I go on?â
Vanner grunted.
Toby continued: âShe wouldnât go back to her flat and she was very anxious not to go to a hotel.â
âWhy?â said Vanner. âHadnât she the money?â
Druna explained: âSheâd been brought up to believe that if she stayed a night alone in a hotel sheâd be abducted. Besidesââand she gave her unexpressive smileââshe was rather fond of putting herself in compromising situations and then behaving platonically. She got some sort of thrill from it. Poor Lou, she was terribly undeveloped. I think I know what Mr Dyke is leading up to telling you: itâs that although he allowed Lou to spend the night at his flat it was all perfectly innocent. You can believe him; it almost certainly was.â
A smothered sound came from Roger Clare. Toby glanced at him. Clare was looking at Druna with intense dislike on his face.
Vanner addressed Druna: âMiss Merton, have you ever seen this cardigan here?â
Druna looked at it distastefully. âNo,â she said.
âDidnât it belong to Miss Capell?â
âIt did not.â
Vanner looked at Toby. âWell?â he said.
Toby shrugged. âSheâd a very bad cold; perhaps sheâd borrowed it from someone to keep her warm. All I know is she left it behind. She was gone in the morning by the time we got up, and there the thing was, over the end of the bed where sheâd slept.â
âSo you thought youâd return it to her, eh?â said Vanner. âHow nice. Thought youâd return it to her just the same evening as she goes and gets herself murderedâvery nice, very nice indeed.â
âYes,â said Toby woodenly, âI thought Iâd return it to her. George and I had nothing special to do, and it was a lovely summer evening, so we thought weâd combine a run in the country on Georgeâs motorcycle with returning the cardigan. We came down here and then we heard this newsâââ
âHeard it how?â barked Vanner.
Tobyâs face showed a bland sort of surprise. âMr Clare here told us all about it.â
âOh, Mr Clare told you, did he? At the garden gate, I suppose?â
âYes,â said Toby, âat the garden gate.â
â And how â said Vanner fiercely, swinging round on Roger Clare, â did you know anything about it? â
A slight catch of the breath sounded close to Toby. It was Eve Clare, who, since her first exclamation when her husband came into the room, had not addressed a single word to him; only, from time to time, she had let her eyes dwell upon him, their expression lifeless. But that lifelessness was so inappropriate to her vivid face that it had revealed how deliberately she found she had to