in the United States of America? Not to look at these lousy company towns here aboutsânot by a long shot! But last year, mind you, 1919, they took seventy-nine million tons of coal out of these West Virginia fields. They undersold Pennsylvania and they undersold Illinois. Up there, most of the operators pay union wages. Down hereââ He flung out his unbandaged hand in disgust. âYou had a look at whatâs down here.â
Trying to pin the conversation down to newspaper terms, I said to him, âYou were elected president of the International Miners Union two months ago, Mr. Holt. I believe youâre the youngest president they ever had?â
âThatâs rightâif you count the years.â
âWhat are your immediate goals?â
âWest Virginia. Thatâs simple enough, isnât it? How long will we have a union in the North if the operators down here undersell the Pennsylvania and Illinois operators and put them out of business?â
âThen you think youâll organize West Virginia?â
âI intend to try,â he grinned. His smile was large and warm and intensely personal, and he had the knack of making you feel that it was elicited by you and directed at you in approbation and flattery.
âWhat would you say your chances are?â
âWorse than they were yesterday.â His smile was gone now.
âIn other words, that gunfight isnât to your advantage?â
âAl, how could it be?â
âWell, the dead men were your enemies, so to speak, werenât they?â
âNo, they werenât my enemies, not one bit. They were cheap, hired thugs, and thereâs a thousand more to take their places.â
âThen you would condemn Fleckerâs action?â
âOf course I would!â he snorted. âDo you think it can bring us anything but trouble? And let me tell you thisâthereâs going to be trouble now, more trouble than anyone will know what to do with. But itâs not trouble that the union asked for or that the miners asked for.â
âDonât you see any way to solve this thing peacefully?â
He thought about that for a while before he said, âIt could be solved peacefully. Any argument can. But one partyâs got to give up something. They want us to give up everything and get out of the state, and I guess that would make peace.â
We talked for another half hour, and then he indicated that the interview was over. I had been making notes, and I told him that I would try to reflect his point of view honestly. He said that was all he asked. We shook hands, and he told me that he would have me driven back to Clinton.
Â
9
The car was a Model T Ford that belonged to the Miners Union. I didnât know then that Laura asked to drive me back. She did a good deal of driving for them, since she knew every road and cart track in the hill country. She was a good driver too, in her second and graduating year at normal school, and had supported herself through both years driving a school bus near Charlestonâthe West Virginia Charleston.
For a little while, coming down from Fenwick Crag, she was silent and attentive to her driving. The sun was low now, and the mountain road, between its walls of trees, was dark and deceptive. On my part, I began a conversation mentally half a dozen times, but whatever I thought to say became banal before I said it. I had slept poorly on the train the night before and been through a long day since then, and I was very tired. I had also been confronted with something totally new to me, met people whose existence I had been unaware of and indifferent to, and witnessed the violent death of twelve men. It added up to a good deal, and on top of that, I was sitting next to a girl I considered both beautiful and desirable. If I had known more about coal miners at that timeâparticularly coal miners in West VirginiaâI might have reflected
Elizabeth Amelia Barrington