could have happened if you hadnât been there. Could you imagine the guilt if heâd lost her too?â
Lovina placed a piece of pie in front of each of them. Only Dat held up his hand, indicating that he didnât want one.
Hope picked up the fork and poked at the crust. âOh, I know who Jonas is, but who was this woman youâre talking about?â
Mem picked up her fork and put it down again. She reached over and took Hopeâs hand, squeezing, as if she had horrible news she needed to share. âIt is Jonasâs wife. Or rather it was Jonasâs wife. Sarah Sutter passed away two years ago, but it was three years before that when she had her stroke.â
âStroke?â Hopeâs mouth dropped open, and her mind tried to wrap around what she was hearing. The room was quiet except for the scraping of forks on plates.
â Ja , they have no idea why,â Lovina said. âShe seemed so healthy before. Itâs just one of those things⦠I suppose we just have to learn to trust God in matters like this.â
Hope placed her fork back on the plate, unsure of what to say. Sheâd been so judgmental with her thoughts earlier, wondering where the girlâs mother was and why she wasnât being tended to.
âSoâso Emmaâs father⦠â
âHeâs a widower.â The words shot out of Memâs mouth. âAnd that little girl. She hasnât had a mother for the last two years. No wonder she was wandering the park today. Where would any of us be without our mothers keeping us on the straight and narrow?â
âSheâs actually been without a mother longer than that.â Graceâs chin dropped to her chest as if the story overwhelmed her. âSarah was paralyzed on one side and unable to speak for three years. Jonas hired in help for both his wife and his daughter, but can you imagine the weight that must have put on a man whilealso tending his farm and being part of the community? No wonder he left Kentucky. Iâm sure he needed a break.â
Lovina cocked an eyebrow. âAre you calling teaching school a break? How would you like to be in the room with fifteen children? Iâd rather be behind a pie display with a hundred hungry customers.â She shook her head. âEverything about this breaks my heart.â
Her mother and sistersâ voices continued, and the words spun around the room. Hope resisted the urge to close her eyes and cover her ears to block out their voices. It had been like this since she was a small girl. All these conversations. All these opinions. It wasnât as if they were saying anything bad or wrong, it was just that they didnât stop talking. She wished they could slow their words and just give her time to think. She put her elbows to the table and pressed her fingertips into her temples, blocking out their words.
Jonas Sutter is a bachelor.
Little Emma doesnât have a mother.
Sadness crept over her like ivy vines, wrapping around her heart.
Then came curiosity.
He was looking at me today. With interest.
Why hadnât Jonas already remarried?
Growing up sheâd seen how things typically worked. It was common for Amish men and women to marry quickly after losing a spouse, often before a year had passed. Amish couples had big families, and a second marriage often became a necessity. Women needed providers for themselves and their children. Men needed help with their home, and especially raising their little ones. Perhaps with just one daughterâinstead of a houseful of childrenâJonasâs need hadnât been so urgent. Or maybe love for his first wife made the idea of marriage a second time difficult.
Or maybe heâs trying to find another person he could love that way again.
A memory filtered through her mind from earlier today. Jonas Sutter had thought ahead to her need, and heâd gotten a blanket for her to cover herself with. Then heâd