I said, âthanks. Black.â
He shut the door behind him, and I didnât need to check to know it was locked from the outside.
A few minutes later he was back. He put a heavy ceramic mug in front of me and left without saying anything.
It wasnât bad for police-station coffee. I sipped it and smoked and sat there in the uncomfortable wooden chair. I assumed Evie was getting the same treatment in an adjacent room.
I didnât need my lawyer training to realize that we were both prime suspects. Dozens of people had witnessed Evieâs confrontation with Larry Scott at the restaurant. Several others had seen him beat me up in the parking lot. The police wouldnât have much trouble learning that Larry had harassed Evie back when she was living in Cortland and that heâd tracked us down here to the Cape.
Means, motive, and opportunity. Either or both of us had plenty of all three. I didnât know anybody else whoâd want Larry dead, but I didnât know anything about him. I hoped Evie could come up with somebody.
I waited nearly an hour before the door opened and two men came in. The bulky, bald-headed one introduced himself as state police homicide detective Neil Vanderweigh. He wore a gray summer-weight suit with a solid-blue necktie that heâd pulled loose. His collar button was undone. The younger blond guy was Sergeant Lipton. He wore a green sports jacket, gray slacks, pale blue shirt, no necktie.
They both shook hands with me. Then Vanderweigh took off his suit jacket, draped it over a chair, and sat across from me. Lipton put a portable tape recorder on the table between us, then went over, leaned against the wall, and crossed his arms.
âAny objection if we record this?â said Vanderweigh.
I shook my head.
He clicked the machine on, recited the date, time, place, and our names into it, then looked up at me. âWhy donât you just tell us what happened this morning, Mr. Coyne.â
I told him about hearing Evie scream, running out of the cottage, and seeing her there with Larryâs body.
He asked if either of us had touched the body. I told him Iâd touched his bloody shirt with my fingertip, that was all.
He asked what weâd done at the crime scene. I told him weâd each smoked a cigarette and ground out the butts on the dirt road.
He asked several clarifying questions. They mostly had to do with timeâwhat time Evie had left to go jogging, how long sheâd been gone before I heard her scream, how long weâd waited before calling the police. I answered the questions as best as I could.
He led me through the events at the restaurant the previous night, and it was clear he already knew all about it.
âDid you threaten him?â said Vanderweigh.
âI donât recall threatening him,â I said.
âYou didnât tell him to leave the woman aloneâor else?â
I shook my head. âI donât think I said âor else,â no.â
âYou donât know what you said?â
I shrugged. âI was angry. He was upsetting Evie. He shoved me and I went after him, and he punched me.â
âYou know that Ms. Banyon had a relationship with Mr. Scott in Cortland a few years ago.â
âI only learned that last night.â
âThat he harassed her for almost a year?â
âThatâs what she told me.â
âDid you kill Larry Scott, Mr. Coyne?â
âNo.â
âDid Evelyn Banyon kill Larry Scott?â
âNo.â
âYouâre a lawyer,â said Vanderweigh. âBe precise, please.â
I nodded. âTo the best of my knowledge, Evelyn Banyon did not kill Larry Scott.â
He smiled at my lawyerly precision. âWhen Ms. Banyon left to go jogging, did she bring a knife with her?â
âNo. She had some pepper spray.â
âWhy did she bring pepper spray?â
âWe were both concerned that she might encounter