know it sounds bad, but we really were in love. Even though nothing happened until I was out of his class, there was some backlash, and that caused problems right from the start.â
âYou landed on your feet, though.â
âDivorce is always painful, regardless of how amicable, but for me it was profitable, at least.â
It seemed Sophie had a mercenary streak, and that surprised him. âEither your ex is generous or you had a damn good attorney.â
She shrugged a shoulder. âLetâs just say I know some things heâd rather others not know, and he was willing to pay me quite a bit of money to ensure no one found out.â
Granted, he didnât know Sophie wellâthen
or
nowâbut flat-out extortion was cold.
She dropped her voice. âI wanted to start my own B&B, so I was happy to take the money, but I wouldnât have told anyone anything anyway.â
Whew.
âYou had me worried there for a minute, Sophie.â
She laughed. âIt hurt my feelings a little that he even asked me to sign a non-disclosure agreement, butââshe laughed quietlyââthe money did help lessen the sting of that. I mean, itâs not like he was involved in something illegal or anything, so there was no moral imperative for me to say what I knew. After all, thereâs no need to destroy someoneâs life unnecessarily.â
Boom.
The guilt landed hard. Sophie had no way of knowing that, though. That was his own conscience dropping the hammer. In his defense, though, he hadnât
meant
to destroy anyoneâs life. Heâd gone looking for one thing but found something else entirely, and how could he have known what Mr. Shipp would do with that information once he had it?
That was his defense. Heâd been a kid, and it had been an accident.
But accident or not, it was still his fault.
For all Sophieâs airy dismissiveness earlier, he heard the bitterness underneath that statement. Maybe the Everclear had loosened her up a little. âNot quite as okay about it as you said, are you?â
She sighed. âItâs hard to explain. I
am
okay with it. Dad and David were wrong to have an affair, and they paid the penalty for that. But it all should have been
our
business. Iâm bitter that Mr. Shipp rained down all that crap on my family when he didnât have to. Iâm bitter he went digging into things that werenât any of his business in the first damn place.â She stopped and cleared her throat, calming herself. âSorry about that. I can get a little ranty about it. People who stir up shit for no good reason just piss me off.â
âThatâs understandable.â His conscience might be telling him to tell her the whole truth, but his good sense didnât want that bitterness turned in his direction. It wasnât just self-preservation stopping him, though. Sophie was not only holding his arm for support, she was also letting her fingers stroke almost absently against his skin in a gentle caress. He didnât know if she was even fully aware of what she was doing, but he liked it and it boded well.
And while he didnât approve of what Mr. Shipp had done with the info heâd naively provided, Mr. Shipp had kept to the journalistic tenet of protecting his source, and there was very little to be gained with a confession now, even if his dishonesty would make the baby Jesus cry. âIâm surprised you came back to Magnolia Beach, then.â
Just like that, the bitterness was gone, and Sophieâs tone turned conversational again. âFrom a business perspective, itâs a wise move. Real estate and the cost of living are quite low comparable to other beach and resort areas, and the Palmer House is ideally located and good value for the money.â
âSo itâs not just nostalgia bringing you back to town.â
âI have a BA from Boston Universityâs School of Hospitality