seemed that way from the girlâs side. Sheâd lost her home and her family and everything sheâd ever known. Then a handsome young soldier saves her.â
âI know. Itâs like a fairy tale from her point of view, but are you saying itâs not the same from his?â
âI donât know. Maybe it was. Maybe rich young men like the idea of saving a young girl in trouble.â
âA damsel in distress,â Sarah said.
âAnd she was certainly that. Iâve never been a rich young man, but I wouldnât want a wife who only married me because she didnât have any other choice.â
âI canât imagine they saw it that way. Surely they were in love.â
âIf she was pretty, he probably
thought
he was. I wonder what she thought.â
Sarah smiled again. âI do know that young men can be as silly as young girls about love.â
âSo maybe they
were
in love, but you said his family wasnât happy about it.â
âHow could they be? They didnât know anything about her, and she probably came to them with little more thanthe clothes on her back. They may have even suspected that she tricked him somehow.â
âMaybe she did. She had a baby right away, after all. Youâve met her. What do you think?â
âItâs funny you should ask. I thought she was remarkably composed for a woman who had lost her only child. Of course, I was taught from birth not to let my emotions get the better of me in public. No one wants to see a woman cry.â
âThatâs true enough, but do you think she was just being proper or do you think she didnât love her son?â
âI canât imagine a mother not loving her son.â
Malloy gave her a crooked smile. âIâm sure you canât. You even love my son.â
âHeâs very lovable. But you love my daughter, so weâre even.â
âYes, we are, but no closer to knowing who might have poisoned Charles Oakes. What about his wife?â
âSheâs a piece of work. All she could talk about was how angry she was that Charles wouldnât take her to Newport this past summer and now sheâs in mourning and wonât be able to go anywhere at all.â
âWhy wouldnât he take her to Newport?â
âBecause he couldnât leave his job.â
Malloy blinked in surprise. âHe had a job?â
âYes, heâd been appointed as superintendent of the Manhattan State Hospital.â
âThe Asylum? Oh, thatâs right. I read about him in the newspapers when it happened. So that was Charles Oakes. But why would he want a job like that?â
Sarah had to think about that for a minute. âI imagine he needed the income.â
âI thought his family was rich.â
âHis family is
old
, and they once were wealthy, but sometimes . . . Well, we donât talk about it, but sometimes the family money runs out or is lost in bad investments or what have you. A lot of families were hurt in the financial panic in ninety-three. Why do you think Theodore took a position as police commissioner?â
âYou mean heâd lost his fortune?â
âThe Rooseveltsâat least his branch of the familyâhave to earn their keep, yes.â
âIs that what happened to the Oakes family?â
âI donât know for sure, and I would never be so rude as to ask them,â she added before he could suggest it. âBut now that you mention it, I did notice that Mrs. Oakesâs mourning gown was past its prime. And maybe Charles didnât take his wife to Newport because he couldnât afford to.â
âSo Charles decided to run the Asylum. Thatâs an odd choice.â
âI doubt he
had
a choice. Young men like him often donât have any skills when it comes to earning a living, so they ask their friends for help finding something. If youâre asking for a favor from
Ned Vizzini, Chris Columbus
Eric S. Brown, Jason Cordova