be?â
âI want you to come to the Commission meeting on Monday night.â
âSo I can tell them theyâre being pansies in person?â
âNo, to watch. I want to know what you think of my performance up there. And if you think Iâm going too far, give me a signal.â
Chapter Five
Rebecca was there, sitting in the front row of the Commission room with a hat, her wristwatches, a smartphone and accompanied by two friends who lived in Lincoln. Then there was Archer, and seated beyond him, Professor Blair Hull, a Harvard sociologist, the owner of the peace sign barn, wearing a tweed sports coat and gray slacks, and his wife. He fixed his gaze at Miranda and studied her face. She made small talkâa difficult taskâwith Nathan Griswold while they waited for Karl to arrive and begin. At 7:00 Karl took his seat and announced they were in session. The agenda, as everyone knew, consisted of several minor items, which were dispensed with in minutes. Then there was âthe suggestion of Commissioner Dalton that the property at 101 Trapelo Road, owned by Mr. and Mrs. Blair Hull, is in violation of section 41(A) of the Zoning Ordinance.â
Karl recognized Professor Hull. He walked from his seat to a microphone and only then focused on Karl.
âCommissioners, our barn is a landmark in this town. It was painted in 1967, and weâre the fourth owners since then. Each owner has carefully preserved it and respected the townâs ordinance. As far as we knew, it was in compliance when we bought it eleven years ago. Commissioner Dalton says itâs two shades off the color chart. She may be right, but the shades of green were chosen to blend in with the landscape. If you order us to change the color, weâll repaint it. It will cost us $6,000 and nobody will notice a difference. But I respectfully suggest this isnât about the color of our barn. Mrs. Dalton has a political motive here. Because she seems so concerned about my politics, I have looked into hers. Sheâs a registered Republican. She gave money to Mitt Romneyâs campaign and George W. Bush.â
âAlright, Professor Hull,â Karl said, âwe donât question each otherâs motives here. I assume the good faith of everyone who appears before us, unless there is some reason not to, and thatâs not a reason to doubt the Commissionerâs motive. Am I right?â
He looked over at her sternly and the room stopped. She decided to double down, showing her unflappability under fireâthe most important lesson General George Patton said one had to have in battle.
âAbsolutely, Mr. Chairman. I noticed the barn because we all notice it. It demands attention. And my eye is trained to these things, the color code, diseased trees, an empty flowerpot at the center of town. I have no idea what Professor Hullâs political affiliation is. If he owns that barn, he is subject to the Zoning Ordinance.â
It was a whopper, but she pulled it off with distinction. Rebecca was impressed. She nodded and gave a thumbs-up. And Karl believed it.
âAlright, Mr. Hull,â he said, âdo you have anything else to say in your defense?â
âNo, sir.â
But Hull was not convinced of Mirandaâs good faith. He stared at her with utter contempt.
Karl declared the debate over and asked for the vote to be taken on whether to approve the issuance of a notice of intent to fine Mr. and Mrs. Blair Hull for their âwillful violation of section 41(A) of the Zoning Ordinance,â quoting the wording from Mirandaâs proposal with emphasis on the word âwillfulâ so as to highlight its adversarial tone.
He asked Julia, seated at the right end of the dais, for her vote.
âI have to say I was quite skeptical of this approach when I first heard it, and Iâve done a great deal of reading about the broken glass theory of policing and some other things Commissioner Dalton
Elizabeth Amelia Barrington