fellow members of the human race will not derail a career. Only when expressed physically are such character flaws judged criminal.
No longer smiling, though still confident, I said, âI decided that it would be more helpful to your son if I got the copsâ side first.â
He didnât like that, but finally got smart enough to say, âI donât see any profit in telling you how to do your job.â
âSoon, I will interview your sonâwhich of course Attorney Roth has already done.â
âWhat do you think of his story?â
âUntil I discover otherwise, Iâm assuming heâs telling the truth.â
He said, âAt first, I couldnât believe how stupid he was to get caught sitting on the machine. But when I went out there to the site I saw how isolated it was. I tried to put myself in his position. All alone, coming upon such a horrible sight, wanting to help, panickingâ¦.â
âYou went there?â I asked.
âI had to see it.â
âWhy?â
âListen, Abbott. All that you and Roth have to do is create doubt. Reasonable doubt that the kid didnât kill that man. Thatâs all we need.â
Clearly, he thought his kid did the crime. If it troubled him to regard his son as a murderer, he didnât show it. And what he said next indicated that as far as he was concerned the trial was nothing more or less than a contest to be won.
âI hired Roth because heâs got a winning track record. What I want you to do is comb the entire goddamned county up there for doubts. Theyâve got no witnesses to the actual crime. Find somebody else who might have done the crime. Find somebody else who wanted to do the crime. Doubt! All we need is doubt.â
âAttorney Roth has already given me those instructions.â
âWell Iâm giving you them too. And Iâll pay a bonus for every seed of doubt you find. Fair enough?â
âIraâs already paying me.â
âWell Iâm going to pay you to try harder.â
âI appreciate your concern for your son. But I donât do things halfway. You donât have to pay me to serve Ira any better than I would without your paying me.â
âMr. Abbott, stop being high and mighty! And stop pretending to be dense. If I have to fire Roth, I donât want to start from scratch with a new investigator. I want copies of all your reports to him.â
âIf itâs all right with Ira, youâre welcome to them. If not, then youâre not.â
âIn that case, Iâll fire him this instant and hire you on the spot.â
I stood up. âThat would put your son at terrible risk. You wonât find a better defense lawyer in Connecticut than Ira Roth, as you already figured out. And if you bring in New York lawyers, the judge will roast them alive. Slowly.â
He surprised me with a brisk smile. âWhere are you going? You havenât had lunch. Come on, sit down. Iâm just mouthing off. Iâm wired about this mess. Fucking kid.â
I sat. He reached for the order chit and picked up the pencil. âWhat would you like?â
âIâll have one of your clubâs famous martinis. Vodka. Twist. Straight up.â
He said, âIâd join you, except Iâve got to go back to work.â
I figured I had already done a very good dayâs work. And it wasnât even one thirty.
He transformed into a thoughtful host, ordering a plate of dim sum to accompany my martini. We both decided upon Cobb salad for lunch and chatted amiably until the drink came. âCheersâI say âfucking kid,â but heâs had a tough time. The divorceâjust at the wrong age. And then all those years living with his mother, who is a piece of work.â
He gazed longingly at my delicious drink. âIt was not a friendly divorce. Knock down, drag out. And I came out of it the villain in the kidâs eyes. Are you