didnât buy it. Charles in the other universe hadnât flipped out and, as Iâd just said, they were basically the same guy. Time to treat my best friend
like
my best friend.
I took his hands in mine. âBut I do know why everyoneâs acting weird around you.â
âSo, tell me.â
âSee, hereâs the thing. Remember when Joey Tucci had asked me to the Senior Prom and you knew he planned to rape me if I didnât say yes to having sex with him somewhere during the night?â
âYeah,â he growled. âI was scared as hell to tell you, because I wasnât sure if youâd believe me, or hate me for ruining your expected good time, but I had to.â
âRight. You told me because you loved me and trusted me to listen to you. You told me I couldnât react the way Iâd want to. And I did listen to you and I didnât go kick him in the balls or run him over with my dadâs car.â
âYeah. You told him youâd gotten asked by someone you liked more and were being kind and not leading him on. Then you asked me instead.â He smiled at me. âThatâs probably my favorite high school memory.â
âIâm fond of it, too.â
âSo, whatâs the thing you need to tell me that you donât want me overreacting to?â
Sent a small prayer up to ACE, Algar, Naomi, and any other superconciousnesses or superpowered beings who might be listening. âWeâve figured out who the Mastermind is.â
Chuckie was quiet for a few long moments. âNo oneâs told me. And everyone started acting strangely once the other Kitty was here. So, that means there was a Mastermind in the world she was from, doesnât it?â
âGot it in one. It was very
Age of Apocalypse
there. People who were good here were bad there and vice versa. People dead here were alive there and vice versa again. But some people were exactly the same, both good and bad.â
âYes, we got a lot of that from the other you.â I could see the wheels turning in Chuckieâs brain. âSo, the Mastermind there is someone I know here, and probably trust, because otherwise, why keep this information from me?â He looked stricken. âIâm not the Mastermind there, am I? Him, I mean.â
âDude, seriously, why are you so down on yourself? No, of course youâre not the Mastermind there, any more than you are here. But to be sure of the overriding theory . . . did you participate in a mail-in chess competition before I met you?â
He nodded. âIn grade school. I won. The people who ran the contest were thrilled. They made a huge deal about it, and I told my teacher, who told the class.â His face clouded. âAnd that was when I learned, definitively, that being known as the smartest person around was the fastest way to being the butt of every joke, the focus of every bully, and more, all of it bad.â
Well, that was exactly how it had gone down for the Chuckie in the other universe, so this wasnât a surprise. It was, however, a confirmation. And the proof that my last hopeful doubts were going to be dashed. âLetâs talk about that some more. Was there anyone who might have, oh, protested your win?â
âYeah,â he said slowly. âI havenât thought about this in years, but now that you mention it, there was someone who was just a little older than me, in high school, I think. He protested my win, for quite a while.â
âDid you ever learn his name?â
Chuckie shook his head. âNo. We were both minors, so his name was kept out of it. He came in second, but refused to accept, so they never shared his name with me.â
âBut yours was shared.â
âYes. I won and my parents and I gave them permission. What does this have to do with anything, or are you just enjoying reminiscing?â
âOh, itâs really significant. Same as
Jody Lynn Nye, Mike Brotherton