year and went to New York. His speech was littered with the old-fashioned, hard-boiled speech of a Bogart movie: dames, broads â that sort of thing.
âHow do you know all this stuff about Rose Mulvanney?â
âThrough extremely delicate questions put to the inhabitants of Clerihew Marsh,â said Macalvie. âLike, did Rose screw around ââ
âIâm sure thatâs the way you put it.â Jury took a drink of cider and could believe in the sizzling throat of the devil.
âBe careful, Freddie makes it herself. My questions to the villagers were more disgustingly discreet. But what turned up when I collared the milkman and the old broad that runs the post office stores was that Rose Mulvanney, a couple of days before she died, started taking more milk and buying more bread. This even though her kid Mary was away on a school trip. The extra groceries went on for maybe five days. Now, she sure as hell wasnât doing that for Sammy Waterhouse. He lived right there in Clerihew Marsh.â
âYouâre saying someone else was living with her?â
âOf course.â
Jury tried not to smile. Macalvie was nothing if not certain of Macalvie. âI agree itâs a possibility.â
âGood. I can go on living.â He popped another Fishermanâs Friend into his mouth.
âSo, assuming the Devon-Cornwall police picked on Waterhouse â why? Months went by before they arrested him, you said.â
âItâs expensive to mount a murder investigation; you know that. They wanted to get him a hell of a lot earlier, except I kept tossing spanners in the works, like trying to convince the effing Devon police that Sam Waterhouse couldnât have moved in with Rose.â
âArenât you making a lot out of extra bread and milk?â
âNo. Rose wasnât buying bread for the church bazaar.â
âThere must have been evidence against Waterhouse. What was it?â
âThat he was always mooning around Rose. He was nineteen, for Godâs sakes.â Macalvie shoved the ashtray to theend of the table. âAnd the dame next door said sheâd heard them having a king-sized row a few nights before Rose died. She saw Sam coming out of the house in a right blaze.â
âAnd Waterhouse â what did he say?â
âHe didnât deny it. He was furious Rose had been âleading him onâ and he really thought she cared. Told him she had another boyfriend, stuff like that.â
âWhat did forensics turn up?â
âTheir hands. They just shrugged. Of course there were prints. All over. Sam had admitted to being in the house. But on the knife? No. Heâd have wiped that clean, said my learned superior. So I said to him, Then why didnât he wipe everything else clean heâd touched? And after the elimination prints â the two daughters and a couple of friends in Clerihew â there were still two sets left over. Could have been anybody, and certainly could have been the guy who did the job, if heâd been living there for a few days.â
âThe girls? The daughters? Where were they?â
âThe fifteen-year-old was off on a school trip. The little one must have been in the house, except for the odd night or two she was sent to play with a little chum from her school.â
âBut that means she must have seen the man at some point â assuming youâre right.â
Macalvieâs look sliced up Jury as good as any knife. Could there be any doubt about a Macalvie theory? âThatâs true. All she had to do was say, âNo, it wasnât Sammy.â And believe me, she would have if she could; she was crazy about Sam. Both girls were. He was very nice to them. So she could have said it wasnât him and maybe identify who it was. Only Teresa never spoke another word.â Macalvie turned to stare into the inglenook fireplace, as if he too might never speak