werenât estranged, it just never occurred to them to call each other. They sent Christmas cards, some Christmases. It took Ricky forever to get the hang of email, but once he was on email, they emailed. Ricky âwasnât much for typing,â though. So they didnât email very often. Point being, Theresa knew what Ricky was saying in evoking their lack of mother â he was acknowledging that they had for years depended on their mother to give a shit on everybody elseâs behalf. Their mother giving a shit was the only thing that kept the family together. It was their mother who, at Christmas, made sure everyone had a present for everyone else. It was their mother who always passed the phone to Ricky when Theresa called on Christmas Eve. Their mother gave Theresa Rickyâs news throughout the year (the divorce, the knee operation) and gave Ricky Theresaâs (the divorce, tenure).
âThe women of our mothersâ generation,â Theresa said to her friends. âThatâs what they do, right? Thatâs their job â to give a shit so the rest of us donât have to bother ââ
Jenn was sprawled on the loveseat shaking her head tightly as she spat an olive pit into her palm. âI get so mad, I get so mad,â she interrupted. âMy mom hauling out the address book every year and writing Christmas cards to everyone sheâs ever met in her life. I mean it takes her days . Then she carries them all over to Dadâs chair for him to sign. It just â it infuriates me! Like heâs had to put any effort into it whatsoever. Gavin â he doesnât get why it pisses me off so much when Iâm sending a present to his mom or someone. He always goes, Hey, can we go in on that together? And Iâm like, No, we fucking canât! I went shopping for your mother . I put actual thought into it. It took me an afternoon of my own free time !And I bought her a card and I wrapped the present and Iâm going to drop it off at the post office . Do you know why you didnât do any of that? Because itâs a pain in the ass! Itâs effort ! But now you wanna get in on it? No! Go and get your mother a present yourself if you want to send her a present.â
Everybody laughed. Jenn was playing up her anger for effect, because who among them hadnât tried to get in on someone elseâs present, piggybacking on another, better personâs kindness? Her friends were being angry in solidarity with Theresa, dredging up their own slights and outrages and laying them neatly down like place settings â napkins, knives and forks.
âSo what happens when women stop giving a shit?â asked Ruth then, trying to turn things into a seminar all of a sudden. You could always hear the âyâ when Ruth said âwomenâ â womyn . Just like she wrote it. They all loved Ruth, but she never âpunched the clock,â as Dana liked to say. Her students all adored her, because she was like them â what her friends referred to, in private, as a âtrue believer.â
Theresa spoke next in order to shut Ruth down â to avoid the classroom discussion her question was meant to provoke and get back to her story. âThe real question is,â she said, âwhat happens when they all die off, our mothers?â
It was not the nicest way to get things back on track. Everyone elseâs mother but Theresaâs was still alive, so every brow but her own was pinched in existential dread. But at least the attention was back on Theresa. This was her particular gift, she knew, after years of running seminars and sitting on panels. She knew how to manipulate the attention of others â to get it where she needed it to be. She knew how to be ruthless when she had to and she knew this was a trait she had inherited.
âWhat happens, I guess,â said Theresa, âsometimes at least, is that people, sons, step up, the way Ricky