Thatâs the American wayâpeople have a right to move in, or move out. Thereâs evidence to point out that white people who moved had something to fear. Who wants to put their kids in a situation where they are likely to be crime victims? Thatâs as basic as life gets.
âIf I were mayor, Iâd declare Detroit a disaster area,â he said. âIt desperately needs national assistance. But Coleman Young has no compassion. He says, âThings have never been better.â What a goddamned lie! The bottom line is, Detroit is an orphaned city. Thereâs no sense that anyone cares. Whatâs happening here is the death of a city.â
In the following months I heard this view repeated a hundred times. It is a constant refrainâblacks, especially black violence, drove people out of their homes and their city. This is the white way to look at it; but Arthur Johnson reminded me that there is another perspective as well.
Johnson, president of the Detroit chapter of the NAACP and a vice-president of Wayne State University, is a scholarly-looking man with thick glasses and a white beard. He leads an organization that for many years symbolized moderation and interracial cooperation. But when we met in his office on the campus of Wayne State, he sounded anything but moderate on the subject of his white neighbors.
âBlacks in Atlanta feel their city is loved,â he said. âHere, white people are proud to say, âI havenât been downtown in ten years.â We know weâre not loved. We know our city has been scarred by the media on an unprecedented scale. I attribute this to the fact that we have a black majority and black leadership. Detroit has unjustly come to represent the worst in America. If they make that stick, itâs possible to justify our neglect and separation.â
Johnson, who serves as one of Detroitâs four police commissioners, is not naive about the cityâs problems. But in his view, they spring not from black incompetence, or violence, but from white hostility.
âWhites donât know a goddamned thing about whatâs gone wrong here. They say, âDetroit had this, Detroit had that.â¦Â But economic power is still in the hands of whites. Itâs apartheid. They rape the city, and then they come and say, âLook what these niggers did to the city,â as if they were guiltless. Then they go out and vote for Ronald Reagan. I look at white working-class people talking about taxes are too high and I donât know them. I just donât know them at all.â
De Lisle spoke about the death of a city; but to Arthur Johnson and the rest of Detroitâs black intelligentsia, something is being born in Detroitâa new, black metropolis.
âDetroit has helped nurture a new black mentality,â Johnson said, pounding his desk for emphasis. âMore than any other city, blacks here make an issue of where you live. If youâre with us, youâll find a place in the city.â
Whites often say, in their own defense, that many middle-class blacks also leave the city at the first opportunity. I mentioned this to Johnson, but he waved it away. âThe majority of the black middle class is here. We are engaged in the most determined, feverish effort to save Detroit. Why? Because Detroit is special. Itâs the first major city in the United States to have taken on the symbols of a black city. It has elected a strong, powerful black mayor, powerful in both his personality and his office. Detroit, more than anywhere else, has gathered power and put it in black hands.â
My own instincts and experience told me that each man was, in his own way, right. It was hard to deny the harsh portrait of the city painted by Tom De Lisle. Judged by the standards of the white middle class, Detroit is an urban nightmare, a place that offers neither safety nor prosperity to its citizens. The American part of me sympathized with
Max Wallace, Howard Bingham