bombing Afghanistan, or some yuppie couple meeting as they fled up Fifth Avenue in the rain of ashes, or the wake-up call about terrorism, or the flag stuff, or the rest of that. And I donât count my surviving. I mean, this thing didnât make me live, it almost killed me. It would have killed me if you hadnât been sick. And not being killed doesnât count as something good coming out of something bad.â
I hated it when she talked like that. Because I didnât feel I could tell her what I really thought: Nothing good was going to come out of this. Sometimes bad things happen, and theyâre just bad. End of story. No compensation. No points earned for suffering. But no one wants to listen to philosophy from a thirteen-year-old, not even the thirteen-year-oldâs mother.
It wasnât until I watched Mom working to make a good impression on bouncy Dr. Bratton that I realized that my being offered a full scholarship to the fanciest, snootiest, most expensive school in northern New Jersey could have been seen by someoneânot by me!âas something good coming out of something bad. In fact, my going to Baileywell was what Mom had always secretlyâwell, not secretly at allâwanted. To me, it was more as if something bad was leading to something even worse. I would explain that to my mom later, as soon as Dr. Bratton left. And it would have been fine with me if heâd left right away.
When had Mom made coffee? Dr. Bratton took his with tons of milk and sugar. We settled inthe couch, from which the plastic cups and Chinese-food containers and pizza boxes must have been removed by elves in the middle of the night.
Dr. Bratton sipped his coffee. All his gestures had a kind of delicate, chirpy grace that I couldnât quite put together with the headmaster of a school for manly bullies and future masters of the universe. Frankly, he reminded me a little of my aunt Grace, who had married a big mafioso and somehow managed to turn into a British person.
âIâm so sorry for your loss,â Dr. Bratton said, and we all did that sheepish nod.
âItâs been hard,â said Mom in a way that made her seem even prettier than normal.
âI can imagine,â said Dr. Bratton. âI mean, I canât imagine.â
âYou canât, actually,â said Mom. A silence fell, and we stared at one another. The ball was in his court.
He tapped his fingertips together, as if he was afraid they might be sizzling hot and he was testingthem to make sure. Then he joined them into a peak, like a church roof, with its spire just under his nose, as if he was sniffing the steeple.
âLike everyone else in this country, in the world ,â he said, âthe Baileywell community has been asking itself what can we possibly do. How can we help, how can we make a difference, how can we react to this terrible tragedy that has shaken us to the core? Of course, a number of our parents and faculty have been going to work as volunteers at Groââ
He stopped short as he got to âGround Zero.â Heâd remembered who we were.
âAnd then we read the inspiring, hopeful story about you and your son, having lost so much and having been saved, by sheer chance, really, from losing so much more. And what I want to tell you, Mrs. Rangely, is that it wasnât your tragedy so much as the whole scenario: a mother who chose her childâs needs over those of her job, a mother who even now must continue to put her professional life on hold because her orphaned childneeds her. And the simple eloquence and dignity with which you, Bart, have dealt with the reporters and with all the interviews that must have been so terribly painful.â
âTo tell you the truth, I was pretty numb,â I said. âIt was sort of like Iâd gotten a big shot of Novocain. So the interviews werenât all that painful.â In fact, I could hardly remember any of my