before. He didnât seem to like me very much.
âEveryone lies to me,â said Detective Sergeant Sheehan.
âYou havenât heard anything yet,â I warned him. âWait till you talk to Oscar.â
âShe was in the bar that night.â
I nodded.
âWho was she with?â
âNo one.â
âWho did she leave with?â
âI donât know.â
âYes you do; she came over to say goodbye before she left with the band. Whoâd you leave with?â
âThatâs personal.â
âDid you see her after she left the bar?â
âNo.â
âDid you call her?â
âNo.â
âDid you go to her apartment?â
âNo.â
âDid she come to your apartment?â
âNo.â
âDid you look for her?â
âNo.â
âWho did she spend time with besides you?â Sheehan didnât smile or change his expression, which suggested he was already looking ahead to something and losing interest in me. Still, he questioned relentlessly, and I felt like a fraud.
âIâm going to find answers.â Sheehan pulled himself up taller, seeming to take up most of my small foyer. âIâm going to know everyone who was in the bar and where they went after the bar closed. Iâll know your personal business, too. I donât understand why you think itâs cool to protect a murderer.â
âBartenderâs code. We only care whether theyâre good tippers.â
When Sheehan left, I tried to figure out for myself what I was doing. I acted out of habit. Not helping the cops was something Iâd learned growing up in Flatbush when the FBI crashed through the neighborhood telling everyone my father was a traitor.
When I arrived at work that night, Saturday night, I found Oscar at his corner of the bar with Sergeant Sheehan. Oscar spoke with a Spanish accent, had black hair, thick black eyebrows, and a pugâs face. He told enormous lies and was impressed by financial successes like doctors and lawyers, and especially business men, some of whom, remembering him from the West End Bar during their college days, stopped by once in a while to say hello. He didnât mind gangsters but hated drug dealers, blacks, and cops. With Sheehan he was having trouble. I could tell by his gestures and the workings of his face muscles that he was telling bigger and bigger lies to get out of the lie heâd just been caught in. Oscar was talking about a lieutenant he thought he knew, while trying to ascertain if Sheehan was on the take so he might arrange something to keep his joint out of the murder case, so he wouldnât lose his liquor license.
If you carry yourself the right way as a bartender, after a while people forget youâre there no matter what kind of secrets theyâre talking about.
âI donât care about your club,â Sheehan said. âI just want one guy.â
âI know, I know,â said Oscar. âMe, too.â
âLook, Oscar. Iâm not on the take. Iâm not after your joint. I just want the perpetrator.â
Oscar wasnât so much unwilling to tell the truthâhe just didnât recognize it. He refused to conform his view of things to someone elseâs idea of reality.
âThe first time she was ever here,â Oscar said, his thick eyebrows bobbing enthusiastically.
âShe was a regular, almost every night,â Sheehan said.
âShe came in but never hung around.â The eyebrows stopped.
âShe was a friend of the bartender.â
âHe never paid attention to her.â The eyebrows crept down over his eyelids.
âShe used to live with him.â
âHe never let on.â Oscarâs eyes squinted closed.
When Sheehan left, Oscar leaned over the bar. âYou got to tell the truth,â Oscar said. âTell him everything you know, or heâll have the place closed. Heâs a big man in the