hand. Touch isnât always felt, in dream. There was a scholar, a politico-philosophical intellect, an enquirer of international morality in the order of the world, a life whose driving motivation was not chosen but placed upon him: Palestinian. An existential destiny, among his worldly others. Itâs cast in the foundations, the academic chairs, honours endowed in the name. All that. But deathâs the discarder he didnât mention. Edward Said is a composer. Thereâs also the baggage you do take. Two grand pianos. Among the living, itâs Carlos Fuentes who asks if music is not the âtrue fig leaf of our shames, the final sublimationâbeyond deathâof our mortal visibility: body of wordsâ. Is only music âfree of visible ties, the purification and illusions of our bodily miseryâ?
Edward. A composer. What he always was, should have been; but there was too much demand upon him from the threatening outer world? Itâs a symphony Edward Saidâs working on now.
âWhatâs the theme, what are you giving us?â Susan is never afraid to be insistent, her passion for all creation so strong this justifies intrusion.
âI donât have to tell you that the movements of a symphony are in sum just that, a resolution, symphonically.â Edward is paying an aside tribute to her non-performerâs love and knowledge of music. âItâs stillâwhat should I sayââ
âYou hear it, you play it? Itâs in your fingers?â Susan is relentlessin pursuit of the process, from one whoâs been an eloquent man of words people havenât always wanted to hear.
He lifts his shoulders and considers. Doesnât she know thatâs the way, equivalent of scribbled phrases, jotted half-sentences, essential single words spoken into a recording gadget, which preceded the books sheâs written, the books he wrote. The symphony heâsâhearing? playing? transposing to the artâs hieroglyphics?âitâs based on Jewish folk songs and Palestinian laments or chants.
Ours is a choir of enthusiasm. When will the work be completed. How far along realised. âItâs doneâ Edward says. Ready. âFor the orchestraâ and spreads palms and forearms wide from elbows pressed at his sides. I read his mind as the dreamer can: just unfortunate Barenboim canât be ready to conduct the work; isnât here yet.
These are people who are accustomed to being engaged by the directions taken by one another, ideas, thought and action. No small table talk. Anthony Sampson takes the opportunity, simply because he hasnât before been able to acknowledge to Susan she shamed the complacent acceptance of suffering as no-one else has done. Since Goya!
Susan gives her splendid congratulatory, deprecatory laugh, and in response quotes what confronts TV onlookers âstill in Time, the pictures will not go away: that is the nature of the digital worldâ. Not long dead, she hasnât quite vacated it: this comes from one of her last looks at the world, the book which Anthony is praising,
Regarding the Pain of Others.
But thatâs for the memory museum left behind as if it were the phenomenon that, for a while, the hair of the dead continues to grow. Susan has brought with her the sword of wordsshe has always flashed skilfully in defence of the disarmed. Sheâs taken up the defence of men.
âYou!â Edward appreciates what surely will be a new style of feminist foil. Weâre all laughing anticipation. But Susan Sontag is no Quixote, wearing a barberâs basin as the helmet of battledress.
âWhat has made them powerless to live fully? Never mind Huntington and his clash of civilisations. The clash of the sexes has brought about subjection of the heterosexual male. We women have achieved the last result, surely, as emancipated beings, we wanted? A reversal of roles of oppressor and oppressed, the