the term ritual, Ms. Phelps? Why didnât you say spell?â
âI donât know.â
âYou do know,â I said. âYouâre not a practitioner. I donât think youâd use the term ritual without a reason. Just think for a minute. Why that word?â
She thought about it, eyes staring into space, seeing nothing, tiny frown lines between her eyebrows. She blinked and looked at me. âI heard him talking on the phone one night.â She looked down, then up, defiant again, and I knew she didnât like what she was about to say. âHeâd tied me to the bed, but heâd left the door open a little. I could hear him talking. He said, âThe ritual will be good tonight,â then his voice dropped too low for me to hear, then he said, âThe untrained ones give it up so easily.â â She looked at me. âI wasnât a virgin when we met. I was . . . experienced. Before him, I thought I was good in bed.â
âWhat makes you think youâre not?â I asked.
âHe told me that I wasnât good enough at straight sex to satisfy him, that he needed the abuse to spice it up, so he wouldnât be bored.â She tried to stay defiant and failed. The hurt showed in her eyes.
âWere you in love with him?â I tried to make the question gentle.
âWhat difference does that make?â
Frances took her hand, held it in her lap. âItâs all right, Naomi. Theyâre going to help us.â
âI donât see what love has to do with any of this,â she said.
âIf you love him, then it will be harder to free you of his influence, thatâs all,â I said.
She didnât seem to notice that Iâd changed loved to love. She answered the question. âI thought I loved him.â
âDo you still love him?â I hated having to ask, but we needed to know.
She gripped the other womanâs small hand in both of hers, knuckles whitening with the strength of her grip. The tears finally slid down her face. âI donât love him, but . . .â she had to take a few deep breaths before she could finish, âbut if I see him, and he asks for sex, I canât seem to say no. Even when itâs awful and heâs hurt me, the actual sex is still better than anything Iâve ever felt before. I can say no over the phone, but if he shows up, I let him . . . I mean, I fight if heâs beating me, but if itâs during sex . . . it gets all confused.â
Frances stood, moving behind the other womanâs chair, spreading the afghan over both of them while she hugged her from behind. She made soothing noises, kissing the top of her head like youâd do with a child.
âHave you been hiding from him?â I asked.
She nodded. âI have, but Frances . . . He can find her no matter where she is.â
âHe follows the spell,â I said.
Both women nodded as if theyâd figured that much out for themselves. âBut Iâve hidden from him. I moved out of my apartment.â
âIâm surprised he didnât hunt for you,â I said.
âThe building is warded,â she said.
I widened eyes at that. For a building to be warded, not just an apartment but the entire building, meant that the protective spells had to be put into the foundation of the building. The wards had to be poured with the concrete, riveted into place with the steel beams. It took a coven of witches, or several covens. No single practitioner could do it. It was not a cheap process. Only the most expensive high-rises or homes could boast of it.
âWhat do you do for a living, Ms. Phelps?â Jeremy asked, because I think that he, like me, had actually not expected the two women to be able to meet our fee. We had enough money in the bank under the agencyâs account and in our own accounts so we could do charity work from time to time. We didnât make a habit of it, but some cases